I just lately performed a examine into the helpfulness (or lack thereof) of zebra striping—the shading of alternate rows in a desk or kind. The examine measured efficiency as customers accomplished a sequence of duties and located no statistically vital enchancment in accuracy—and little or no statistically vital enchancment in velocity when zebra stripes have been carried out.
Article Continues Beneath
These outcomes have been a shock to many readers of the corresponding article, revealed in A Record Aside in Might, 2008. I believe it’s truthful to say that the overwhelming majority of us, myself included, anticipated to see that zebra striping helped loads.
Due to these shocking outcomes, I made a decision to conduct two extra research into the worth of zebra striping. These research aimed to check design parts intentionally excluded from the primary examine, and to deal with a number of the points raised by the outcomes of the primary examine.
This text represents a abstract of my analysis, presenting the findings of those two additional research and offering a advice on future use of zebra striping.
Is zebra striping analysis actually needed?#section2
Earlier than leaping into the findings of the brand new research, I want to take a second to replicate on whether or not analysis on this matter is definitely a “waste of time,” as a result of the usefulness of zebra striping is “apparent.”
A few years of conducting person analysis have taught me that what looks like an apparent alternative to at least one particular person is disliked by one other, and sometimes for good purpose. Within the case of zebra striping, the profit (i.e., of main the attention) appeared doubtless, however I had a niggling concern about potential downsides (e.g., extra visible noise interfering with cognitive processing).
Curiously, since writing the primary article, many individuals have informed me that they usually debate using zebra striping of their work groups. These debates truly offered my authentic motivation—I anticipated the primary examine to discover a clear profit from zebra striping and due to this fact present a statistic that would assist such discussions. As a substitute, these authentic outcomes made the image much less, quite than extra, clear! To me, this implies that extra analysis was warranted.
Directing analysis energies#section3
The experimental knowledge produced by the preliminary examine didn’t assist a powerful argument for zebra striping. But a single experiment just isn’t ample to disprove a concept: perhaps zebra striping had little impact due to that experiment’s specific design. Positive, zebra stripes might not assist a lot when you’re presenting a desk just like the one from that examine—which is in reality one thing value realizing, all by itself—however what if the desk was longer, the stripes have been a distinct colour, or the duty was more durable? This was a priority that my readers and I shared.
In a great world, I might conduct a examine for each potential design attribute that would affect whether or not zebra striping helped or not. Nevertheless, these attributes are prone to embody a minimum of the next:
- variety of rows and/or columns,
- density of the textual content,
- quantity of white house between rows and/or columns,
- how excessive the rows/large the columns are,
- what number of colours are used for the striping,
- which colour(s) is/are used for the striping,
- the diploma of distinction between the striped and non-striped colours,
- whether or not rows are shaded in teams or singly, and if the previous, what number of rows are in a bunch,
- what different types of tables the person has been uncovered to previously,
- how a lot time the person spends with the desk,
- how a lot the person has to modify between utilizing the desk and different duties,
- the diploma of strain on the person when they’re working with the desk,
- the kind of knowledge that the desk accommodates (e.g., textual content or figures),
- whether or not the person has a pointing gadget (e.g., mouse or digital pen), and
- how essential the duty is to the person.
For a small enterprise proprietor resembling myself, it’s simply not possible to conduct all this analysis. However I did wish to observe up on one facet of the preliminary examine design that notably bothered me: the shortage of actual strain skilled by individuals when taking part. To my thoughts, in the event you give somebody a limiteless period of time to carry out a job, they may use that point to carry out the duty effectively, particularly in the event that they consider accuracy issues. To place it one other manner, the preliminary examine might have had a low variety of errors as a result of individuals have been being cautious to get the reply proper, so the good thing about this added consideration outshone the good thing about zebra striping.
The second examine: an alternate examination of efficiency#section4
As such, I felt it was essential to conduct one other examine: one which restricted the period of time individuals needed to reply and created a little bit of strain across the job. I additionally felt it was essential to make the duty itself more durable. These ideas guided the design of the follow-up examine that was linked to on the backside of the unique ALA article (and elsewhere).
Like the primary examine, the follow-up examine requested individuals to reply eight questions utilizing a desk of unfamiliar info (see determine beneath). Otherwise from the primary examine, customers have been offered with the questions in a random order, and the model of desk (plain, lined, or striped) that accompanied every query was additionally randomly chosen.
A timer within the high proper hand nook of the display helped create a way of strain. Individuals had 15 seconds to reply every query: when the time elapsed a message was displayed and the participant was taken to the following query. Any reply that the participant had entered by the point the 15 seconds elapsed, even when partial, was captured; individuals might additionally commit their reply earlier than the time elapsed, through the use of a “submit” button.
So as to add to the problem of the duty, the desk included clean cells and a better variety of rows, in order that vertical scrolling was prone to be wanted. On this sense, the desk was just like an internet banking assertion (a typical use of tables on-line).
A whopping 3,674 browser periods have been begun for this follow-up examine, which was performed April 29–June 15, 2008. From these, I eliminated periods wherein roughly than eight questions had been answered. I additionally eliminated all however one session (chosen at random) when a number of periods have been submitted from the identical IP tackle. (This sledgehammer method was the one method to get rid of duplicates. It can have additionally meant the lack of some legitimate knowledge, however we have been involved to forestall any bias from repeat participation.) These measures left 2,276 clear survey periods that could possibly be used for evaluation.
Solutions have been labeled as both right or incorrect, in order that accuracy could possibly be analyzed. A solution was thought-about right if it was a minimum of partially right (e.g., “philli” or “Philipins” for “Philippines”). This was carried out so that individuals weren’t as deprived by their typing velocity, if that they had discovered the correct reply however not entered it totally when the time expired.
This desk of knowledge was used within the second examine on the advantages of zebra striping. Individuals have been requested to reply eight questions utilizing this info, with 15 seconds given for every response. The desk was offered both plain, lined, or zebra striped; the striped model is proven.
Regardless of there being solely eight questions and three types, this follow-up examine has yielded an extremely great amount of knowledge.
I haven’t analyzed all of it—and possibly won’t ever have time to—so in the event you’re enthusiastic about getting a duplicate of the information set and operating your individual evaluation, be happy to contact me.
The important thing outcomes, nonetheless, are proven beneath. Yellow highlighting signifies instances wherein the higher efficiency with the striped model of the desk are statistically vital primarily based on Pearson’s Chi-Squared Goodness of Match exams. (These exams regulate for the completely different pattern sizes every desk model had.) Orange highlighting signifies the case that’s extraordinarily near being statistically vital (p=0.0545).
The outcomes of the second examine confirmed that zebra striping improved accuracy on three of the eight questions requested.
The desk exhibits that for 3 of the eight questions, the striped model yielded a extra correct response than did the plain and lined variations. A fourth query comes very near being statistically vital. For the remaining 4 questions, the distinction in accuracy between all three types is so small that it can’t be statistically separated from random noise. In these instances, efficiency with zebra striping is simply pretty much as good as—and definitely no worse than—the plain or lined model.
Which means, on this examine a minimum of, zebra striping doesn’t hurt efficiency—and in lots of instances, it truly results in an enchancment.
The third examine: person desire#section5
A second subject raised by plenty of readers was that the worth of zebra striping is expounded to aesthetics and/or subjective desire as a lot as precise enchancment in efficiency. This can be a strong argument and one which I made on the finish of the unique article: if customers like zebra striping, then it’s nearly a moot level whether or not it truly helps them learn tables extra simply (offered it doesn’t make studying tables more durable).
With a view to use desire as an argument for implementing zebra striping, we’d like a statistic that exhibits that almost all of the person viewers prefers it. For this third examine, I selected most people because the person viewers, in order that the outcomes have been as broadly relevant as potential (i.e., not simply derived predominantly from the online developer group). With the beneficiant assist of Newspoll, I used to be in a position to ask a query about desire on considered one of their Nationwide On-line Omnibus research. The Nationwide On-line Omnibus is a web-based survey of simply over 1,200 Australians aged 18-64. The survey accommodates completely different questions each fortnight—organizations purchase a number of questions for inclusion. The survey individuals are members of Newspoll’s rigorously maintained market analysis panel, and the outcomes are weighted to supply estimates for the Australian inhabitants. Due to this fact, we may be assured within the representativeness of those outcomes, for the Australian inhabitants a minimum of (and possibly additionally for the populations of different related nations, resembling america, Canada, New Zealand, and Britain).
Individuals have been proven the next picture —which offered the identical desk six occasions, every utilizing a distinct model of formatting—and textual content:
The tables of knowledge used to measure person desire for plain, lined, and variations of zebra striped tables.
The tables have been accompanied by the next directions:
Clearly, there are various different types (e.g., three colour or mixture of lined and striped) that could possibly be examined, however a technical limitation meant the variety of types could possibly be not more than six. In selecting these six types out of all of the types potential, we took into trương mục the next elements:
- The will to definitively reply the query: “Do individuals desire zebra striped tables in comparison explicitly to plain and lined tables?”
- Sure alternate options to plain, lined, or single-color, single-row appeared to be fashionable amongst readers of the unique ALA article (e.g., two colour, single row).
- That grey is impartial and due to this fact ought to have the ability to be used for zebra striping usually (e.g., no matter company branding constraints and monitor sort).
- That inexperienced is simple on the attention (we’ve extra inexperienced receptors than crimson and blue ones) and is taken into account in lots of instances to be calming.
The necessity to keep away from types which are prone to create an excessive amount of visible noise (and thus make readability worse quite than higher).
To attenuate order results, it could have been preferable for the order wherein the tables appeared within the picture to be random, however sadly this was not potential. As a “subsequent smartest thing,” related types have been bodily separated, to make the order seem random. Additionally, the model that was considered least favored (plain) was put within the place that eye monitoring research inform us receives essentially the most consideration (the highest left-hand nook). This fashion, if there was a desire away from this model, this discovering couldn’t be discounted because of the poor location of the desk.
The outcomes of this third examine are proven within the graph beneath. The standard zebra striping method (single-color, single-row) is essentially the most most popular: 31% of individuals rated it because the desk that helps essentially the most and solely 4% rated it because the desk that helps the least. (Notice that the utmost margin of error on these estimates is 2.8%.)
The third examine confirmed individuals most popular single-row, single-color, zebra striped tables.
The 2-color, single-row method appears to divide the inhabitants, with 23% of the inhabitants contemplating it one of the best method however 15% contemplating it the worst method. These outcomes make sense: we will think about using two completely different colours might represent additional visible cues for some however additional visible noise for others.
Curiously, at 20%, the lined model is most popular nearly as a lot because the two-color, single-row model. It additionally has—just like the single-color, single-row model—solely a small proportion of people that dislike it, at 4%. The opposite attention-grabbing result’s the poor final result for double and triple-striped, every being most popular by lower than 10%. Triple-striped can also be the least most popular possibility for nearly a 3rd of the inhabitants (28%). Whereas this can be a mirrored image of a real dislike for these approaches, the dimensions of the tables used within the survey could possibly be an element. Due to house limitations, the tables might solely have seven rows, probably making it much less clear that the double and triple striping was a sample that will be repeated all through the desk. I personally assume the rationale behind it—that it offers extra visible info than single row striping, by way of “chunking” of knowledge—makes lots of sense. Nevertheless, it’s potential that individuals simply don’t prefer it as a lot as the opposite types.
The outcomes of the three research performed to this point counsel that the most secure possibility is to shade the alternating, particular person rows of your desk with a single colour. Taking this method is probably going to make sure that:
- job efficiency is best, or a minimum of no worse, than with different desk types, and
- the aesthetic sensibilities and subjective preferences of the vast majority of your customers are catered for.
If zebra striping of this kind can’t be carried out simply, then ruling a line between every row would be the subsequent most suitable choice.
One door closes and one other one opens#section7
It feels as if we’re getting someplace when it comes to having dependable and legitimate statistical knowledge to again up our alternative of zebra striping for tabular knowledge on-line. Nevertheless it continues to be potential to punch holes within the research yielding this knowledge. For instance, perhaps individuals have a subjective desire for single-color, single-row striping as a result of it’s what they’re used to (like utilizing blue underlining for hyperlinks). Familiarity might additionally clarify the shortage of assist for double and triple striping, approaches which will effectively enhance job efficiency considerably.
What are we to do? I believe the reply is twofold.
Firstly, if, in your specific circumstance, the fee related to implementing single-color, single-row zebra striping is suitable—and I’ve been informed of a number of instances the place this isn’t the case—then this must be carried out. In any other case, stick to a plain or lined design.
Secondly, in case you are designing an software or web site that accommodates knowledge tables, don’t let private desire, behavior, or the (untested) established order drive your design choices—go on the market and get some person knowledge. Run some exams utilizing your most popular method and a number of of the alternate options described right here. And in the event you can, share your outcomes with us, so our information of the efficacy or in any other case, of various types of tabular knowledge, can develop.
 Notice that the picture was proven at a dimension of 749 pixels large by 403 pixels excessive.